Saturday, November 15, 2008

It started with an email to the American Prospect

So I sent this email to Ezra Klein and he responded with a pretty great post. I was happy with the comments it generated for the most part. I learned a lot that I hadn't realized.

However one problem I have with the situation is that people are so convinced that teacher merit pay is going to be based on some stupid assessment, no one seems interested in trying to find a good assessment.

Perhaps the best example of this I can think of was one commenter (who's mother was a long term teacher) who stated:

"[My mom] is dead set against merit bonuses...and here's why, from the trenches: good public school, or private school, faculty...they SHARE. Share ideas, share work, share materials. You institute true merit pay and not only does all that stop, with every person an isolated competitor, but resentments would build beyond belief. A school is a GROUP activity, not investment banking."

Now all of this is a good point, however it assumes that teachers are going to be put in competition for paychecks. So if I am a great teacher, and you are a great teacher, I can't get a raise unless I'm greater than you. I definitely agree that this would be a problem with teacher assessment, one that would destroy learning communities in our schools, so lets not do it. Lets ensure that whatever method of assesment is around doesn't give those bad sort of incentives. Agreed? Agreed.

The point is that this is all still up in the air, with nothing set in stone yet in most regions. So we could construct a teaching assesment that we were happy with if we wanted. This blog will look into research (which clearly I need to do more of) and try to direct a discussion towards a goal of assessing teachers that rewards teachers for things that we actually value (whatever those things end up being, another topic of conversation.) 

I'm sure I'll mostly be talking to myself here in the beginning, but I appreciate any and all comments. Especially productive ones.

Nate

Edit: Trying to make fonts and sizes match (first blog).